Fake News

Submitted by Josh Jasper:

How local TV embraced fake news
Americans’ first source in news is overrun by marketing videos.
by Farhad Manjoo

Note: Here is another excerpt from my new book, True Enough: Learning to Live in a Post-Fact Society. (For previous excerpts, see here and here.) The book argues that new communications technologies are loosening the culture’s grip on what people once called “objective reality.” Here, I look at how fakery has overrun local TV news.


Excerpted from True Enough by Farhad Manjoo (Wiley, 2008)

story-200.jpgLate in the holiday shopping season of 2005, Robin Raskin began to worry about a hidden danger posed by the world’s most popular gadget: Pornography was popping up on the iPod. Raskin, a pert middle-aged woman with short brown hair and a deep, authoritative voice, considered herself an expert on how kids use technology (she’d once written a magazine column called “Internet Mom”). She approached local TV news broadcasts across the country with her iPod worries. They bit.

“There’s scores of ‘iPorn’ everywhere,” Raskin warned in an appearance on KGUN, an ABC affiliate in Tucson, Ariz. The iPod had become “a pedophile’s playground,” she said, and Apple was doing little to stem the smut. On Pittsburgh’s Fox affiliate, WPGH Channel 53, Raskin called the iPod one of the “scariest” gifts of the season. The ABC station in Columbus, Ohio, featured Raskin’s warnings as part of a report by Kent Justice, a correspondent who produces a regular segment called “On Your Side.” Justice told viewers, “If you didn’t know it, now prepare for it: Hundreds of Web sites are selling iPorn.”

Nine stations aired Raskin’s warnings. Her segments had the look and feel of ordinary local news: Super-coifed anchors offer alarmist assessments of everyday objects, story at 11. Continue reading “Fake News”

“Pop Fiction”: Celebrities Unite Against the Media… Sure

Editor’s update: The Toronto Star did a more probbing story on Ashton Kutcher’s new television series “Pop Fiction” the purpose of which is purportedly to teach paparazzi a thing or two. Called “Paparazzi, you’ve been punk’d”, it aptly ends with a flourish:

Pop Fiction wants the world to know celebrity journalism is unfair, blinkered, mendacious, ridiculous and abusive.

I’m not defending anything or anyone. But if it wasn’t for celebrity journalism, the world would not care about these people in the first place.


As reported here on March 9, 2008:

Hilton’s ‘Guru’ Date Was Set Up for Kutcher”s New Prank TV Show
by Wenn
Hollywood.com
March 6, 2008

Paris Hilton"s Sugar SweetHollywood – Paris Hilton’s night out in Hollywood with a bearded ‘guru’ last Saturday was staged by Punk’d star Ashton Kutcher for a new TV show, designed to exploit the media.

Hilton made headlines around the world when she stepped out with an orange-robed, grey-haired ‘shaman’ who proceeded to bless her and then encouraged her to donate a diamond necklace to a stranger.

However, as previously reported by WENN, the ‘guru’ was actually an actor named Maxie Santillan Jr..

And it has now emerged that the incident was a prank for Kutcher’s new show Pop Fiction, which will feature 20 celebrities, including several superstars, who are all in on the joke.

Kutcher and his business partner Jason Goldberg produce the new program, which highlights the gullibility of the paparazzi and the media and is set to premiere on E! on Sunday.

Goldberg says, “We live in a culture that’s driven by media and obsessed with celebrity, to the point where they don’t have private lives anymore.

“Two people going out to eat turns into, ‘They’re engaged.’ It’s a feeding frenzy. It’s dangerous and it’s irresponsible in some cases.

“We’re having fun, but we want to say to people, ‘Can you really believe everything you read and see?'”

photo: Dave Edwards © 2008 DailyCeleb.com

thanks Susan

When Johnny (aka Prince Harry) Comes Marching Home

Harry’s tour dismissed as ‘failed stunt’ by PR guru
Public won”t be fooled by “˜virtual reality” deployment, says Clifford
by Sam Marsden
Independent.ie
March 2, 2008

Top publicist Max Clifford yesterday launched a broadside at Prince Harry’s tour of duty in Afghanistan. Clifford said the tour was a “PR stunt” that has not fooled the public.

AP Video:

The Household Cavalry officer’s 10-week deployment to the frontline in Helmand Province was “virtual reality” because army chiefs would have kept him away from real danger, the PR guru claimed.

It will not change British public opinion about Harry as people reflect that there are thousands of ordinary British troops serving in Afghanistan without receiving the same special treatment, Mr Clifford added.

“To me it’s blatantly obvious. It’s a PR stunt, the whole thing has been put together,” he said.

“The climate when he went out, (he) was getting increasing bad publicity from hanging around in clubs and pubs, and coming out drunk.

“It happened immediately after that. I don’t think you’re cynical for saying, ‘hold on a minute’ … I think that most discerning people see it as a pure public relations exercise.” Continue reading “When Johnny (aka Prince Harry) Comes Marching Home”

Journalist Bites Reality!

From Skeptic.com:

In this week”s eSkeptic, Steve Salerno discusses the fundamental flaws of broadcast journalism as a tool for informing viewers.


Journalist-Bites-Reality!
by Steve Salerno
eSkeptic.com
February 13, 2008

How broadcast journalism is flawed in such a fundamental way that its utility as a tool for informing viewers is almost nil.

news_screenshot-200.jpgIt is the measure of the media”s obsession with its “pedophiles run amok!” story line that so many of us are on a first-name basis with the victims: Polly, Amber, JonBenet, Danielle, Elizabeth, Samantha. And now there is Madeleine. Clearly these crimes were and are horrific, and nothing here is intended to diminish the parents” loss. But something else has been lost in the bargain as journalists tirelessly stoke fear of strangers, segueing from nightly-news segments about cyber-stalkers and “the rapist in your neighborhood” to prime-time reality series like Dateline”s “To Catch a Predator.” That “something else” is reality.

According to the U.S. Department of Justice, in a given year there are about 88,000 documented cases of sexual abuse among juveniles. In the roughly 17,500 cases involving children between ages 6 and 11, strangers are the perpetrators just 5 percent of the time “” and just 3 percentof the time when the victim is under age 6. (Further, more than a third of such molesters are themselves juveniles, who may not be true “predators” so much as confused or unruly teens.) Overall, the odds that one of America”s 48 million children under age 12 will encounter an adult pedophile at the local park are startlingly remote. The Child Molestation Research & Prevention Institute puts it like so: “Right now, 90 percent of our efforts go toward protecting our children from strangers, when what we need to do is to focus 90 percent of our efforts toward protecting children from the abusers who are not strangers.” Continue reading “Journalist Bites Reality!”

Who Do You Believe, Me or Your Lying Eyes?

House candidate mum on doctored campaign photo
His aide says there wasn’t time for photo session
by Alan Bernstein
Houston Chronicle
January 18, 2007

U.S. House candidate and former Sugar Land mayor Dean Hrbacek"s head on another man"s bodyThe brochure that U.S. House candidate and former Sugar Land mayor Dean Hrbacek mailed to voters this week says, “Dean’s record speaks for itself.”

But his physique does not. In a photo next to the words of praise, Hrbacek’s body is spoken for by the torso of an appreciably slimmer man.

The picture, presented as a true image of the candidate, is actually a computerized composite of Hrbacek’s face and someone else’s figure, in suit and tie, from neck to knee caps. The give-away is a flawed fit of head and collar.

Hrbacek, a tax lawyer and accountant, did not return calls about the campaign literature Thursday. He is among 10 Republicans seeking the nomination to run against U.S. Rep. Nick Lampson, D-Stafford.

But campaign manager Scott Broschart admitted the image is a fake. Continue reading “Who Do You Believe, Me or Your Lying Eyes?”